When We Finish Buffy & OC What Should Replace Them?

Monk is a great show, and episodic mysteries are fun to watch

Anna

Lol, to be honest most the shows on this list aren’t even good

Nathalie 9090

dawson creek!

colton

spoil the first episode some more, will ya ;)

Thomas Becker

I personally hate this idea. I am someone who is a completionist and the thought of purposely starting a show and not finishing it is horrifying. I have found other reactors who start a show I love and then after one or two seasons drop it because they just didn't get into it and I won't even watch them react to the show because I don't want to deal with starting something I know i'll enjoy but never get to see all the way through.

Zach Faulkner

I would love to see Dawson's Creek and Grey's Anatomy. When it comes to reactors, there's a lot of shows that most or all of them seem to do. Dawson's Creek and Grey's Anatomy are ones I've always wanted to watch someone react to but no one ever does them. A reactor I follow finally started Dawson's Creek about a month ago but it's my favorite show of all times so i'd love a second reactor. I still have not found anyone who does full length Grey's reactions.

Zach Faulkner

I saw someone else starting to review True Blood on TouTube and I've just said to myself that I want to rewatch it. I haven't seen it in years. Also two of the cast members just started a podcast where they actually watch the show because they never have before. So I'm listening to that and it's four episodes in. So I guess True Blood is making a come back.

Valencia Lanier

Greek is such a amazing show..so sad it has so little votes.

Stacey

im happy charmed is winning but i wish monk and dawsons creek got more love

Leonard Atkins jr

I think Gossip Girl and Pretty Little Liars would be fun, but I’d say you have to relish in the kinds of shows they are, and not have too high expectations. They are pillars in teen drama, but PLL in particular, is not really concerned putting any depth or substance into the storyline beyond your shocking twists and turns.

I Am Not Chamari

If I could vote Greys Anatomy a thousand times I would also charmed tho but Greys anatomy!!

Jana Fuller

One day I hope you react to Sherlock. It's a really great show with 4 seasons (3 episodes per season), but each episode is around 90 minutes long. I do think you'll enjoy it whenever you have time.

Nic

awkward. would be great

sn

True blood one day! 🤞🏼

Alondra

My dream is that one day someone does Everwood.

Slayerette

Charmed!!! Hopefully that wins.

Amaya

It looks like charm is going to win but if u get a chance greys anatomy is great and no one does it

I think if u continued watching Merlin you would like it it has alot of lore and the acting is top notch plus the scenery and wardrobe really pull u in to the story.

Magical Creature

i based my vote on what i think you'd actually like and not which show i like the most. you seem to enjoy vamp shows (buffy and vampire diaries). so i voted true blood. although i would love to see you react to gossip girl, based on your lack of enthusiasm over some of the other teen shows you watch, i'm not sure you'd like it past season 1. also i would never force anyone to sit through 7 seasons of pretty little liars based on the last few seasons. especially knowing your disdain for unanswered questions and plot holes lmao.

cil

Just gonna say it, for Pretty Little Liars and Greys, you'd be impressed the first few seasons then suffer through the rest. It gets pretty wtf as the seasons go on. Might not be the best to commit years to reacting to those.

Nyssa Rawther 🍉

Same, i would like some different shows.

Mariella Nilsson

this would be great to replace Psych

Amanda Winner

thats a lot of tv! that are 20 seasons of 22+ episodes, of which the latter half isn't that great. please don't commit to the whole show....

Thomas Becker

just going by popularity alone might not be a good way to select new shows, because some might just not know the different shows. of course everyone knows grey anatomy, so there are many votes. i think it is equally important you like the show you are reacting to, to create a interesting reaction. i doubt many here have seen switched at birth or everwood. so they won't get many votes, but would imho make for better reactions, than grey's.

Thomas Becker

I have a general suggestion for your tv show reactions: certain shows have really strong first season that are fantastic to watch/react to, because the plot moves along relatively fast. for example the amount of story progress in the first seasons of gossip girl or pretty little liars is stunning. unfortunately that slows to a crawl in the following seasons. personally i'd be really interested in seeing reactions to those first seasons with all their twists, but not the rest. how about you announce just a single season for some shows. and gauge the reception afterwards so there is no disappointed feedback, if you stop. plus you are not committed for literally years.

Thomas Becker

I would really recommend you react at least to the pilot. it is really good show that is abit different to all the other teen shows. and it's a show that is well suited for a reaction, because it has a little more depth. i personally think, you would like it. sort of gilmore girls vibe without being that silly.

Thomas Becker

OG Charmed should definitely replace Buffy. They were on the same network at the same time and everyone compared them back in the day. They are very similar in a lot of ways. Most Buffy watchers would also likely watch Charmed.

Terri

I'm also going to throw in a recommendation for Third Watch (1999). After 15 years, the series is FINALLY on a streaming service (Roku Channel). Six seasons of the best first responder show there is.

cruzinbosco

Euphoria !!!

pholla

Switched at birth! I am BEGGING you! I love the show and would have loved to see someone react to it, but noone seems to have ever done it

Lena Oertel

Dark

Omar Vargas

Charmed I think would be the best replacement for you with Buffy. Monk I think would be a really good replacement for you with Psych being done.

Kenzie8814

Honestly, out of all of the shows, Everwood is near the top. Its honestly a more mature teen drama and it has a dueling cast of adults and teens similar to the OC. Plus it has good drama and interesting storylines. It's short, only a few seasons, so it would be less of an investment of time compared to greys anatomy or some of the other shows.

JustRushOnce

It will take you 10 years to catch up to Greys lmao. Charmed is the closest to what Buffy is and in terms of teen shows the best ones are Skins and Pretty Little Liars.

PhoebeG

I honestly think you would hate both Secret Life and Riverdale. I am a teen drama junkie and even I can't get through them. I tried. Still trying with Riverdale but the storylines take too long to complete because the seasons are so long and they need to throw in random crap in the middle of them to fill it out. Secret Life is just a mess. Loved the first couple of seasons but it quickly got out of hand. Just my opinion.

cruzinbosco

grey’s anatomy please god

madeline z

He's already seen that. He mentioned it when he started Gilmore Girls.

cruzinbosco

I think one of them definitely needs to watch Life Unexpected, however.... they are not at the right place yet in One Tree Hill for it. The crossover would spoil so much for OTH.

cruzinbosco

I would watch the majority of these. Gossip Girl, only if it's the original. The new one is fun and all, but the original is the one I would want reactions to. One of my favorite crazy shows. Everyone is already reacting to the new one, but no one does the original.

cruzinbosco

Wow, this is the first list I've ever been interested in none of them. I'd vote X-files for the classic scifi slot and Downton Abbey or Search Party for the soapy or young drama slot.

Jojo77

Crazy ex girlfriend is incredible and extremely underrated!

Michelle

Gossip girl to replace the OC if I remember correctly they have the same show runner and true blood to replace buffy the vampire slayer for a supernatural component

Grace

Looooove Ugly Betty!

Shana

I also recommend Revenge, Life Unexpected, Instant Star, or Outlander. Alias could be good too. Out of these, Felicity, Everwood, Jane the Virgin, or True Blood. Also like Dawson's Creek and Gotham but voting for the one's I'd rather see. Felicity is probably my favorite of those and I haven't seen any reactions.

Leora Nechama

Ugly Betty, Monk & True Blood are three of my favorite shows

Chael

Greys anatomy

I actually loved the series switched at birth it was drama filled series that’s about two families who’s daughters were switched at birth on the day of their birth at the hospital (one of the daughters is deaf and the other one is hearing and both families try to adapt to the ways on how to communicate using sign language and struggle to understand the struggle of what deaf people have to go through in their everyday lives. Sadly they canceled the series but I wish more people would react to it

PinkNaomi Love

One day Torchwood is gonna win lol

Jonathan Giles

Monk is a lot of fun (though I don’t think it will win against such juggernauts).

Sonia Deepak

welp guess riverdale never getting a reaction lol

vince

Original Charmed for sure, I'd vote for Dawson's Creek whenever you need a replacement for probably OC or OTH.

Tia

Charmed to replace Buffy and Ugly Betty to replace OC. It would be a nice change from the teen dramas. Grey's is just too long and I dunno...the magic dies down after a while. Monk should replace Psych though. Merlin is also phenomenal.

Nyssa Rawther 🍉

Gotham and True blood are Amazing !!! 😄

charlotte

Please add fringe to the list to see how it does

Tracy R

Greys anatomy!!!!!! no one ever reacts to it

Victoria Chinaka

It seems like either Charmed or Grey’s Anatomy will win which I’m fine with, but I see some underrated gems that I would love to see you guys react to eventually. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Awkward, Kyle XY, and Greek are shows I don’t see anyone reacting to.

Clay W

I mean personally I would like to vote for Faking It as a write in.

Silvern7552

As always I would love to finally see a reaction from Steven to FRINGE!!! It was supposed to be the replacement for Person of Interest, but I have given up hope that Steven will listen to us.

Primus

Charmed!! I’d LOVE that

Therese Larsen

Pretty little liars would be good

Kristen Maddox

Same I just voted for Skins 😂

Danielle

Would love to see you react to torchwood finally and it isn’t too long but apart from that greys anatomy and pretty little liars would be really great :)

Teeoni Leigh

Omg Skins plss, it's iconic!! 😭

Michel Stephany Garces

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel , free with prime video, one of the best shows I’ve seen in a while. About a wife and mom from the 40’s who finds a new calling “comedy”. Great show and I’m a guy.

CHRISTOPHER RUSSELL