Lost in Adaptation: A Christmas Carol Part 2

It seems no one can hate that film...

Dominic Noble

Great video. Also nice to know someone else shares my point of view - I don't care at all for the Christmas season, but I really love the Muppet Christmas Carol. Go figure.

Enjoyed it immensely, though you misspoke and said that the 1984 version had your favorite ghost of Christmas past instead of future in the best adaptation category.

Mitchell Reid-Tait

Yays! I'm so glad the Muppets won, though now I want to see the 1990s one and the Jim Carrey one. Glad you liked watching the movies, even if the season isn't for you. Prospero ano y felicidad, Dom

Felicia Angel

I couldn't find a copy of it anywhere. I could find 1935 and 1938 but not 1931 for some reason.

Dominic Noble

No 1931 at all? I really liked the Ghost of Christmas Present and Scrooges Nephew.

Tanner Corcoran

I think this is one of your best videos to date! BTW, this is unrelated, but if we ever do reach the level where you do television series, would Penny Dreadful even be possible, given just how many different works it adapts into it's hodgepodge (Frankenstein, The Wolf Man, The Portrait of Dorian Grey, Dracula, Dr Jekyll and Mr. Hyde...)

Serpen Thrope

Yayyyyy, Muppet Christmas Carol has been one of my favorite movies of all time, I'm glad it's pure hearted nature and big efforts shown through to you Dom.

I enjoyed this immensely and as I'm sure I've written before I hope you make this an annual thing. It is after all the only possible way to tackle the big one, ALICE IN WONDERLAND by Lewis Carrol. I just typed that title into IMBD and came up with 172 titles. Oh my fur and whiskers! That's one Mad hatter of a list even if all the TV episodes and shorts are left off.

Kim Huett

You could do this for The Jungle Book to tie in with the Disney film coming next year (or later this year if you are reading this in a a few hours from now)

Buc Reviewer

Fantastic job! I agree with Jami--this is a format I'd love to see you do again. It's so thrilling to watch you and the show grow and adapt with things like "In Name Only" and now the DomOscars. Your flexibility and willingness to try new things will serve you very well in the long run, I think. I also like that you separated the final two awards into "Most Accurate" and "Best"--I wholeheartedly support the Muppets getting the latter award, but I think defining the categories separately means that there was no loss of critic cred at all. :3 A Merry Bah Humbug to you!

Amy Reynolds

Theres got to have been at least 4 movies before DomOscars will work. I'm only aware of 2 hunchbacks and 1 phantom not counting theater productions?

Dominic Noble

That was awesome. Now I actually do want to see you do Phantom Of The Opera and The Hunchback Of Notre Dame - if you do them in this same way. I've already started to think of my nominations for Phantom. There's going to be some Channel Awesome people who will be disappointed Marley wasn't included. And I'm still a Scrooge myself. Bah humbug to both Christmas and Valentine's Day.

Sooooorrry that was my bad. Fixed now.

Dominic Noble

"Video is private." Guess I should've waited a few minutes.